This year as I lit the Menorah on the 6th night of Hanukkah, this is what I wrote
“Every night I have to sit in my darkness and light these candles. Literally a light in the darkness for 8 whole nights; and it doesn’t make anything better, and it doesn’t make me feel any better at all. It makes me feel worse sometimes because I don’t see that light right now. But it also feels really important”
And so, with that, I started thinking about the way we are meant to hold light and darkness all in one hand. We must hold the deepest grief and the greatest rejoicing all in one hand. That feels so counterintuitive; when we’re happy we are meant to be ALL happy, and when we are sad, we are allowed to just feel sad, and that’s okay. I’m not talking about negativity during your good times “Well its happy for now, but it’ll get bad again eventually” and I’m not talking about a toxic form of positivity “Nothing is really that bad, I’m sure there’s something good about it.”
I’m talking about something that transcends all that. The ability to hold the good and bad together in one hand without changing either one. Allowing them to exist in the same space without explaining away their full nature.
Psalm 139: 12 says, “Yea the darkness hideth not from Thee; but the night shineth as the day: the darkness and the light are both alike to Thee”
I want to pick that apart for a moment, because at a first glance you can easily pass it off as “oh yeah, dark is the same as light because God makes everything light” but that’s not actually what it says. The line that can be interpreted that way “the night shineth as the day” is surrounded by important key verses that indicate it should not be read that way. Because of that, this line always made me feel unsettled. I thought “is this scripture really saying that God doesn’t change the darkness, that the darkness does not flee from him?”
To me as a teenager, that felt very close to blasphemy, and so I just explained it away or ignored it. But there was a problem… Psalm 139:7-12 was my favorite passage of scripture, I had it in my notebooks and up on my wall, and so I was met with that line day after day, wrestling with it. And in all that time, I don’t think I understood until just recently.
“Yea the darkness hideth not from Thee; but the night shineth as the day”
In Genesis, when Adam and Eve sinned against God, they hid. They tried to retreat into their darkness and hide from God, to avoid being seen by Him, for fear of judgement. But our darkness does not hide from God, because even the darkness bows to Him, even that is ultimately under His authority. That doesn’t mean that He bids the darkness to come against us (We know that He does not tempt us James 1:13) but regardless, when He speaks into the darkness with authority it MUST obey Him, and it cannot hide from Him, and we cannot hide from Him within that darkness.
“The darkness and the light are both alike to Thee”
God can see us, and reach us no matter where we are, darkness and light make no difference to Him, neither one has authority over Him, and neither one can cut us off from His love for as long as we draw breath.
There was a picture circulating for a long time of a crossroads between the “good road” and the “bad road” as they were labeled, and the person is shown walking down the bad road… and Jesus is standing at the crossroads waiting for Him to turn around and come back.
That picture broke my heart.
Even when we turn away from God, He never turns away from us, He never leaves us in our sin or shame or darkness. He does not stand at some distant crossroads waiting for us to come back, He travels with us ALL the time, regardless of where we are going. Turning to Him is not a process of finding our way back alone until we finally come back to that crossroads, it is as simple as acknowledging that He is already beside us and ALL we must do is follow Him back to where we are going.
And more than that, when we are following Him, we will still walk through darkness. We will suffer heartache, loss and grief, loneliness, exhaustion, depression, anxiety, longing, and so many other things in this life. But again, whether we are sitting in the darkness or sitting in the light, it is the same to God.
“The Lord Himself goes before you and will be with you, He will never leave you nor forsake you. Do not be afraid; do not be discouraged,” Deuteronomy 31:8
So finally… this picture of Hanukkah…
When Jesus, the light of the world sits with us in the darkness, He doesn’t always light up the whole place like we imagine. When I light the Menorah, it doesn’t brighten the whole room, especially on the first night. But in that space, the darkness and the light reside together.
We hold all this in one hand.